MAC Award (Manhattan Association of Clubs & Cabarets) 2008 Nomination
--Best Comedy/Improv Group

2008 Nightlife Award Nomination (New York City)
-- Outstanding Comic Group

OUTmusic Award 2005 Nominations
-- Out Musician of the Year
-- Best Musical Group
-- Best Producer (I Wanna Be a Republican)

San Francisco Bay Guardian Readers' Poll
-- Winners, Best of the Bay 2003

OUTmusic Award 2003 Nomination
-- Out Musician of the Year

Contemporary A Cappella Recording Awards 2002 Nomination
-- Artist of the Year

Drama Desk Award Nomination, Ben Schatz
-- Outstanding Lyrics 2001 for "Dragapella! Starring the Kinsey Sicks."

Lortel Award Nominations
-- Best Musical and Best Costumes 2001 for "Dragapella! Starring the Kinsey Sicks."

GLAAD Media Award Nomination
-- for "Dragapella! Starring the Kinsey Sicks."

Contemporary A Cappella Recording Awards 2000
-- Comedy

West Coast Harmony Sweepstakes 1999
-- Audience Favorite Award & Best Song